The local government watchdog has found Bromsgrove District Council failed residents after investigating a villager’s complaint over Marlbrook Tip.
An award for compensation has been made against the council by the Local Government Ombudsman to remedy the “injustice” caused.
The amount of the compensation awarded to Roy Hughes, a lead campaigner in the overtipping debacle, is not known.
He revealed the ombudsman’s decision at the December meeting of the Marlbrook Tip Working Group, set up to keep residents informed of progress towards resolving problems caused by overtipping more than a million cubic metres of spoil on the south side of the Lickey Hills.
The ombudsman came to his decision on October 16, but this was the first time it had been made public.
Mr Hughes, whose home backs on to the tip, told the meeting: “I was extremely surprised that the ombudsman’s decision wasn’t communicated to members of this group immediately.”
And Coun Luke Mallett, leader of the opposition Labour group at the district council, said: “I would doubt that this decision would have been made public if Mr Hughes hadn’t brought it to this meeting.”
But Sarah Sellers, a senior solicitor at the council, told the meeting: “This ombudsman’s report wasn’t one that we have to disclose to the council.
“The decision came through quite recently, some time in October. We don’t have any duty to make this information available.”
She added: “That information is now open and in the public domain, but I think the council would have been in breach if it had made it public.”
The ombudsman found that the council failed to respond to residents’ continued complaints of overtipping, referring complainants to reports provided by the site’s consultants.
This was despite the council not even receiving any reports of how many lorryloads were arriving at the site from May 2006 to February 2007.
“When the council continued to receive complaints, it should have looked into them rather than referring those complaining back to the reports,” said the ombudsman.
“As residents continued to report concerns, I consider the council should have looked into the true state of tipping on the site by the end of 2006–beginning of 2007.
“Failure to do so is fault. If the council had inspected the levels on the site at that point it would likely have identified the reports were not accurate.”
The ombudsman cleared the council of failing to take enforcement action after tipping was halted, being satisfied the council intended to take action and even though there were delays, any action would have had to be abandoned when the Environment Agency became fully engaged this year over concerns of a “reservoir” on the site.
In conclusion, the ombudsman, referring to Mr Hughes as “Mr B”, said he had “found fault by the council which caused injustice to Mr B. I am satisfied the action the council will take is sufficient to remedy Mr B’s injustice”.
See The Village View
