ADVERTISEMENT FEATURE
Greater transparency doesn’t always make it easier to see, writes Paul Lyons.
Investing money in non-deposit based investment solutions is engaging more and more people as wealth grows.
However, there remains a huge gulf in difference between the various solutions that are marketed to individual investors, from the banks to the likes of fund supermarket providers to Independent Financial Advisers.
Much of the talk recently has been around conversion to “clean” shares or in some cases “super clean”. This does not mean that there is any such thing as a “dirty” share class, but while these terms have entered financial vocabulary, it is clear that many do not understand the relevance of the term.
Historically, many investment wrappers were created with the cost of the wrapper provider being paid from a rebate, paid directly from the funds in which the investor put their money.
Example of a retail share class:
* Annual Management Charge 1.50%
This is made up of the following constituents:
* Rebate to investment supermarket: 0.85%
* Cost and profit for investment manager: 0.65%
This promoted the view that the investor could get access, through a fund supermarket, to many collective investment funds at the same price as if they had gone direct to that company. Whilst true, it was always possible to negotiate some special terms on certain investment funds.
The problem with this approach was that it was not very transparent and did not fulfil the objectives that the regulator, the Financial Conduct Authority, had for the industry.
There has therefore been a pressure for investment firms and investment wrapper providers, to adopt a far more transparent share structure for their investments.
The result has been “clean” share classes. These are not new, but are often institutional share classes that actually have been available for many years.
The big difference between these and the retail share class is that there is no rebate costed into the share class. The result is that the institutional or clean share classes have an annual management charge of perhaps 0.75% per annum and pay no rebates.
If you are invested in a retail share class then don’t despair. Many investment providers more recently have being paying a part, or in some cases, all of the additional rebate back into the plan as cash to buy more units, with a result that in some cases retail shares can prove cheaper than clean shares.
For those who think their fund supermarket is going to be happy to get paid less going forward, they should think again.
The reality is that many, probably the best example being Hargreaves Lansdown, have changed the charging structure on their plans in order to impose a charge to replace the loss of the rebate.
For many, this has inflated the charges that they are paying going forward significantly, reflecting the scale of the loss of rebate to the fund supermarkets.
One benefit of charging a separate fee is that it will allow these investment wrappers the potential to invest in a far wider range of assets going forward.
Whether they do will remain to be seen, but the inclusion of direct assets, Investment Trusts and Exchange Traded Funds is no longer a pipedream. The benefit for the investor should be in more diverse and therefore safer portfolios.
This brings me to “super clean” share classes. The first thing to say is that these may either be the clean share class or a completely separate share class. The “super” refers to an agreement with the investment manager to further reduce the cost of the share class, below that which would be charged for the clean share class.
While this, on the face of it, sounds really positive, it may be expected that super clean shares will see the biggest inflow of funds. We know that one of the biggest reasons why an investment underperforms is when a huge inflow makes sensible investment decisions impossible.
The moral of this story is that while cost is important, it is not everything and investment return is definitely an important consideration.
In summary, when considering investing capital, it is important to understand the total cost of investing. This includes the cost of funds, the cost of the wrapper and importantly, other non-standard costs that may be present, but not so visible.
Investing in a diverse well-structured portfolio appropriate to your attitude to risk, is also of very high importance if you are to get the best out of your investment.
Finally, taking financial advice may not be as costly as you think and in many cases, the cost of going direct is not as attractive as it may appear.
If you would like to discuss any of the topics within this article, or would like to talk to one of our IFAs, please do not hesitate to contact us:
Tel: 01527 577775
Email: mail@ afhgroup.com
Web: https://www.afhwm.co.uk
AFH Wealth Management is a trading style of AFH Independent Financial Services Limited, which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.
This article is for generic information only and should not be construed as advice. Please contact us before proceeding with any course of action.
