HomeFeaturesfinanceEU law forces us to shoot ourselves in the foot

EU law forces us to shoot ourselves in the foot

-

Austin Broad laments the consequences of insurance gender ruling.

While sexual equality has been largely accepted in the UK, there are times when the issue can be taken to extremes that result in outcomes that do not benefit either sex.

In March 2011, the European Court of Justice ruled that a person’s gender could no longer be used as a factor when calculating the price of insurance contracts.
On the face of it, one would perhaps look at this and feel it does not outwardly sound unreasonable. However, the implications and perhaps unintended consequences of the ruling are profound.

It is also a further example that the UK is not in control of its own law as this ruling is binding on the UK. Indeed, from the 21st December 2012, this ruling will become binding on insurance companies in the UK.

It is a fact that while life expectancy has been on the increase for both sexes, men still have a lower life expectancy than women. It is also a fact that men on average have larger pension funds than women when they reach retirement.

At retirement, pension funds are used to purchase an income stream for the remainder of your life, through either the purchase of an annuity or a drawdown arrangement, where income is drawn directly from invested funds.

In calculating the income that can be paid, life expectancy is assessed as one important factor.  As women live on average longer than men, the annuity rate for men is higher than that for women.

The result of the ruling will therefore be, that from 21st December 2012 the income purchased for men, who on average have larger pension funds than women, will fall and at a time when the investment returns used in calculating these rates are at all-time lows.

This could be argued as a suitable outcome if, the annuity rates for women would increase significantly as a result of the fall. However, it is expected that due to the cost of implementing these changes women’s rates will not increase significantly.

Such is the concern of the UK Government that they have ruled that the Government Actuaries Department will not reduce the rate used in calculating the amount of income that a male can draw from his pension fund, but rather that women will be able to adopt the current rate that is used in the calculation of a male’s pension.

The consequences do not stop there, however. Life assurance premiums and critical illness premiums are also set to rise as a consequence. The result is not expected to be a reduction in premiums for women, but a significant increase in the cost of providing this type of essential protection for our younger, most vulnerable families.

At a time where budgets are already squeezed in these times of austerity, further upward pressure will be applied to these budgets in an area that is essential planning for most working families.

Finally, let’s turn our attention to car insurance. We know, often through bitter experience, that young men or “boy racers” are much more likely to have a car crash than our young ladies, although at times I find this hard to believe when I see my daughter’s driving!

The consequence of this ruling will therefore be that the insurance companies will no longer be able to take this into account in calculating insurance premiums. The result is that premiums for women will increase significantly, while the premium for those most at risk will fall, slightly.

So what can be done? Well for any men approaching retirement it may be worth at least speaking to your adviser to assess what the impact will mean to you and whether there is an argument to bring the transaction forward.

Likewise there may be good sense in reviewing your protection plans and you should consider whether there is an opportunity to take advantage of the current rates.

Perhaps the best thing however, would be for us all to consider how we can apply pressure to the powers that be, in order to stop the constant flow of ill-conceived laws from Europe that seems to result in us having to shoot ourselves in the foot.

The content of this article is generic and should not be construed as specific investment advice. Please contact us before proceeding with any course of action.

AFH Wealth Management is a trading style of AFH Independent Financial Services Limited, which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Services Authority.

For more details or to sign up for the AFH e-newsletter, visit https://www.afhwm.co.uk

Austin Broad is Technical Director at AFH Wealth Management.