HomeFeaturesfinanceWith or without?

With or without?

-

ADVERTISEMENT FEATURE

‘With profits’ policies may just be gathering dust, writes Austin Broad.

Twenty years ago the term “with profits” was the staple recommendation of financial advisers from the banks to the independent sector. It was something of an enigma, with very few understanding how it worked, but the returns were good and therefore the appetite to buy it was unerring.
Much of this perceived strength was derived from annual valuations that showed positive returns in any investment conditions and a lack of transparency in the way that the valuations were written and the funds were run.

However, this changed when Equitable Life failed after setting unsustainable, inflated annual bonuses and maturity guarantees, over many years. This, along with the attention that this directed on other with profit funds, was the beginning of the end. Funds were forced to become much more transparent in the way that they reported to their investors and ran their funds.

The bad press resulted in outflows from the sector and pressure on solvency requirements forced many with profit houses to announce 0% annual bonuses to investors.

More importantly, these changes in solvency requirements forced many insurance companies into selling equities at the bottom of the market in favour of more stable fixed interest stock, that did not hold the potential, in the long-term, of real growth.

Finally, pressure on the financial advice industry to encourage professional qualifications resulted in a greater knowledge and sophistication amongst advisers, which and in conjunction with, the wider availability of portfolio planning tools, allowed advisers to recommend multi asset investment portfolios designed to be diverse and use investment managers specialist to the asset in question.

But where does this leave the myriad investors who still hold investments in “with profits”? Is there any merit in continued exposure to this asset class?

As one might expect, the answer is not straightforward and to begin, it is important to stress that there are huge variations in the quality and viability of with profit investments between insurance companies. The concept of a long-term managed fund, utilising smoothing techniques in order to calm and rationalise the peaks and troughs of investment markets, is one that still appeals to many investors.

The pressure to improve the transparency of with profit funds and the way they are run, has provided for a much healthier sector for new investors in the few companies continuing to market the concept.

For existing investors, the starting point is to determine the health and status of the with profit company that you are invested in. There is much more information published than previously was the case and every “with profit” fund manager is obliged to publish their Principles and Practices of Financial Management (PPFM).

This document details how their fund is managed, the smoothing techniques used and how profits are distributed. This document will provide a useful starting point for research.

There are two types of with profit plan. Older policies are often “conventional” with profit plans. At outset, a basic sum assured provides the guaranteed maturity value if all premiums are paid. Each year, the bonuses declared are added to this guarantee and become in themselves guaranteed at maturity.

At maturity, the performance of the fund, net of charges, is compared to the guaranteed basic sum assured and bonuses are declared. If the fund performance has been better than the bonuses declared, a terminal bonus is paid to enhance the return.

There is no guarantee that a terminal bonus will be paid. The provision of this basic value at maturity is potentially valuable, dependent upon the bonuses and some managers previously guaranteed minimum bonus rates which further enhance this type of plan.

The second type of with profit plan is the unitised with profit plan and these are the more modern version. The principle is much the same, except that at outset a fixed number of units in the fund are allotted and annually a bonus is declared. This is then added to the unit price on a daily basis.

Once added to the plan the unit price cannot fall back. At maturity, the same valuation as above is followed in calculating whether a terminal bonus is payable.

The problem comes on early sale, as at this point, in the event that the underlying fund hasn’t performed sufficiently to support the bonuses added to units, a Market Value Adjustment (MVA) can be applied, reducing the value of the reported funds. Many of these types of policy do not have a maturity date.

Returns at maturity are all about charges during the term and the investment management of the underlying assets. In general, in the long term, funds that are able to invest freely and maintain a good exposure to equities are expected to outperform those that are forced to invest in safer fixed interest stock.

By looking at the historic equity exposure and comparing across the industry, it is possible to gauge the prospects for future returns within the fund. This information can be used along with information on financial strength of the underlying company to gauge future potential and compare with values offered.

It is a fact that some with profit funds are almost entirely made up of cash and fixed interest stock and are paying no bonuses. In the long-term, for this type of policyholder, future returns would be viewed as bleak. For others, the fund can be 65% invested in equities, thus providing the potential for real growth over inflation in the long-term.

As can be seen, it is essential that investors understand what they have and are realistic in their future investment expectations. It is possible to source and interpret the information required to make an informed decision, but for those who are less confident about obtaining and interpreting this type of information, it is sensible to consider asking an independent financial adviser to carry out a review.

AFH Wealth Management is a trading style of AFH IFS Ltd which is authorised and regulated by the FSA. Past performance is not a guide to future performance. The value of investments and the income derived from them may go down as well as up. Please contact a financial adviser before taking any further course of action.

For more details or to sign up for the AFH e-newsletter, visit https://www.afhwm.co.uk

Austin Broad is Technical Director at AFH Wealth Management.