
Above: Joshua Davis in a picture supplied by West Mercia Police.
One punch ended the life of a 50-year-old Alvechurch man in the toilets of The Red Lion pub in the village.
Today a 20-year-old West Heath man was beginning a 28-month jail sentence after admitting manslaughter.
Joshua Davis, of Marden Grove, cut a small, remorseful figure in the dock at Worcester Crown Court this afternoon as he faced Judge Alistair McCreath for sentencing.
He had pleaded guilty to the manslaughter of John Parkinson, a single man who lived with his mother in Alvechurch, at an earlier hearing after the charge was reduced from murder.
Today his barrister, David Crigman QC, told how “in a matter of about 90 seconds, his world, his fiancee’s world, his parents’ world were shattered and Mr Parkinson lay dying”.
The court also heard that since the attack, Mr Parkinson’s grieving, elderly mother had also died.
Gareth Walters, for the prosecution, outlined what they knew of events on Saturday January 15.
He said Mr Parkinson’s brother, Roger, would visit John and their mother at their Alvechurch home most weekends and on this Saturday he dropped off his wife off in Redditch to do some shopping and then drove to Alvechurch, arriving at about 2pm.
At about 3.30pm John suggested they drove to a public house, which they did and stayed until about 5pm, during which time John drank about three pints of cider.
After Roger left to meet his wife, John went to the Hopwood Inn where he continued drinking until about 8.30pm, after which he went to The Red Lion in Alvechurch.
Left: Police tape seals The Red Lion on Sunday January 16 2011 after the incident.
There, the defendant and his partner were standing with the defendant’s brother in a group of friends at the bar after having a meal at the pub.
“It was between 9.45 and 10pm that John Parkinson got up from the table where he had been sitting and walked by the bar to the toilets,” Mr Walters continued. “His route led him past the group at the bar.
“Later blood analysis showed he was nearly three times over the legal driving limit and as he walked past he was clearly unstable.”
Mr Walters said: “A waitress heard one of the group say, ‘Someone has just touched my bum’.
“From CCTV inside the pub, John Parkinson can then be seen walking away from the group towards the toilet and bumping into an empty chair.
“Two males, the defendant and his brother reacted to what the girl had said. Both men at that point started to head off after John Parkinson.”
Witnesses reported hearing one of the group saying: “Leave it, he’s only an old man”, said Mr Walters. “The defendant’s brother stopped and turned back. The defendant did not.”
At this point the CCTV footage ended, but medical reports showed Mr Parkinson to have suffered a “significant blunt impact to the right side of his jaw and upper neck.
“The obvious cause of that being the hard punch by the defendant,” said Mr Walters.
“That blow caused a tear in a major artery in the brain which caused extensive brain haemorrhage. That would have caused almost immediate collapse. The other significant injury was to the back of the head, consistent with falling backwards.”
“The defendant went straight back to the bar and was heard by a witness to say, ‘I just done him; we need to go.’” said Mr Walters.
“At that moment the group left, leaving unfinished drinks on the bar.”
Mr Walters told the court how Mr Parkinson had been discovered almost immediately after the attack collapsed on the toilet floor and staff and customers attempted to revive him, but he was pronounced dead after arrival at the Alexandra Hospital, Redditch.
Mr Crigman, for the defence, told the court: “This case illustrates just how fragile life can be.
“On this particular Saturday night, this defendant, 20 years of age, was standing at the bar of a very respectable country, family pub having a drink with his fianceé and two other couples who had taken their meal there.
“He had had very little to drink. He was in a happy relationship that had been going on since he was 15 and he did not have a care in the world.
“In a matter of about 90 seconds, his world, his fiancee’s world, his parents’ world were shattered and Mr Parkinson lay dying.
“He not only had no previous convictions, he had never hit anyone in his life before.
“The real tragedy is that in 99 times out of 100, there may have been a bruise or a bloody nose. The odds of it producing death are long in the extreme.”
Mr Crigman said the defendant was “small in stature, probably 5ft 6ins – Mr Parkinson was 6ft 2ins. He was at the urinal on a raised step. When the defendant went into the lavatory he went and stood alongside him.”
According to the defence, Davis said he asked if Mr Parkinson had pinched the lady’s bottom and was “told in no uncertain terms” to go away and was slapped. It was then that he punched Mr Parkinson from the side.
“Mr Davis was worried he would get up and fight him and wanted to run away,” Mr Crigman told the court, saying the defence disputed the prosecution’s version that he wanted to get away to evade being apprehended.
The Judge then pointed out: “The fact of leaving is the nub of it. The trouble is, he left a man on his own in a lavatory who was going to die, although he would not have known that.”
Mr Crigman continued: “They learnt on the Sunday morning that this was a very serious incident and at 6.30pm he surrendered himself to Redditch police station and denied murder.
“Things will never be the same. Mr Parkinson has gone. This defendant carries the responsibility of it; it is a burden that he has to carry.
“Since January he has been in a nightmare; he is in a world of prisons and men in gowns.
“But that is secondary to his feelings about Mr Parkinson. That a man has lost his life because of something he did will never leave him. I have never seen him smile,” said Mr Crigman.
Sentencing Davis, Judge McCreath told the court: “The first thing that needs to be said is that nobody in the course of this hearing has suggested for a single moment that John Parkinson deserved what happened to him. He emphatically did not.”
“The second thing that I must say is that the sentence I must now pass cannot reflect the value of that life lost. How could there be any such measure?
“I am acutely aware of the effect his death has had on those who mourn him,” said the judge. Referring to the death of Mr Parkinson’s mother since the attack, he added: “The reality is that she was to die soon after him and the life that was left to her was filled with grief.”
The judge told Davis: “I bear in mind that you are young; I bear in mind that you have no previous convictions of any kind and that what you did was entirely out of your normal character.
“I recognise that in doing what you did, you had no intention to kill and no intention to do any really serious injury.
“I accept that you are genuinely shocked, riddled with guilt and remorseful for what you did.
“Your plea of guilt entitles you to a discount of one third on the sentence you have to serve.
“It may be that John Parkinson, after taking significant drink, misbehaved himself on the way to the lavatory, but that did not in any sense mean that he deserved what happened to him.
“What you did was to follow a man who was manifestly drunk to the lavatory. Only two people know what happened in the lavatory and only one is left speaking. Whether words were exchanged, I know not, although I think it likely.
“It is asserted that he slapped you. Whether or not that is true, as you stood at the side of this man you struck him a considerable blow.
“Your thought was all for yourself and you quickly left the scene, leaving a dying man behind you.”
“This violence was unnecessary. I can’t think that you had any intention other than to cause him some injury when you followed him to the lavatory.”
Admitting that the sentence would seem harsh to some and lenient to others, Judge McCreath sentenced Davis to two years and four months in a young offenders’ institution, with a reduction for the time he has already spent on remand.
After the hearing, Det Ch Insp Damian Barratt, of West Mercia Police, said car numberplate recognition technology had been used to track down Davis.
“Davis and his friends had booked a table for a meal in the name of Davis. When the murder investigation was launched, ANPR (automatic number plate recognition) technology was used to establish which vehicles had passed through the area at the relevant time and a car registered in the name of Davis led us to him,” said Det Ch Insp Barratt.
“This case clearly demonstrates that a single blow to the head, which in normal circumstances would probably only cause a fairly minor injury, can sometimes have tragic consequences.
“Davis had no previous convictions, and was not known to the police. He must live with the result of his actions for the rest of his life.
“Mr Parkinson’s family are still trying to come to terms with their loss, and our sympathies and thoughts are with them.
“West Mercia Police would like to pay tribute to those staff and customers who attempted to resuscitate Mr Parkinson prior to the arrival of the emergency services, and to the paramedics and doctors who tried so hard to save his life.”
