HomeFeaturesfinanceCautiously optimistic on the stock market

Cautiously optimistic on the stock market

-

Economist Colin Warren sees a bright side for equities.

With the FTSE 100 up over 20 per cent since its March low, the UK stock market is now officially back in a bull phase. But given the violent moves of the last 12 months and the uncertain outlook, retail investors are understandably wary of buying in to the market. 

At times like this, a sober analysis of valuation and the balance of risks is required. On this basis, there are grounds for cautious optimism.

Investors seek to buy assets when they offer good value. But how do we know when a share price is attractively priced? One popular method is to look at the price/earnings ratio, which compares a company’s share price to its annual earnings. For the UK stock market as a whole, this ratio is currently 8.5, down from a peak of 27 reached during the dotcom bubble and well below the 40-year average of 14.

Many analysts prefer to look at the cyclically-adjusted price/earnings ratio, which evens out the ups and downs of the business cycle by using earnings averaged over 10 years. But even on this measure, the conclusion is bullish: the stock market this year has offered better value than at any time since the early 1980s.

As well as looking at historical comparisons, it is also useful to compare equities against other asset classes. In this regard, the income that investors can earn from holding shares – the dividend yield – is also historically attractive versus Gilts and cash.

Even adjusting for the fact that the banks which have sought assistance from the government will not be paying dividends, the FTSE is currently yielding 5.1 per cent. This represents an excess or “spread” of nearly two percentage points over 10-year Gilts and more than four percentage points more than the paltry rates currently being offered on instant access cash ISAs.

Of course, these attractive valuations do not guarantee that share prices will rise. Earnings are clearly being squeezed hard. But improving economic data suggest that the outlook has brightened considerably since early March, when fears of bank nationalisation and a second great depression stalked the markets.

Several so-called leading economic indicators, such as new orders and consumer confidence, suggest that the worst of the economic downturn is now behind us, and credit conditions are improving. Given the unprecedented global fiscal and monetary stimulus witnessed in recent months, there is growing optimism that the economy will return to positive growth during 2010.

Encouragingly, some corporate earnings have started to beat analysts’ forecasts. Furthermore, with the Bank of England set to keep policy loose for an extended period, the balance of risks are now shifting from deflation to inflation.
Although fears of a period of hyper-inflation are overblown, central banks around the world will be keen to let economies gain momentum before tightening policy, suggesting some moderate medium-term inflation risk. With corporate earnings linked to nominal growth, this is another argument for holding equities.

Against this backdrop, investor sentiment has shown a marked improvement. Volatility has fallen and there are signs that, with the capacity of the hedge funds reduced, longer-term investors are playing a greater role in driving the markets.

Of course, there are still many hurdles to overcome; the banks still have the capacity to disappoint and over-extended consumers face the prospect of years of debt repayment. As a result, global growth is unlikely to return to the super-charged rates of the go-go years any time soon, and the stock market recovery will not be in a “straight line”.

Nevertheless, given attractive valuations and an improving economic outlook, there are good arguments for long-term investors to increase exposure to the equity market.

(written on May 7, 2009)

Colin Warren is the Chief Economist at AFH Independent Financial Services Ltd in Bromsgrove. For more information call 01527 577775.