HomeNewsBG Parish CouncilPacked meeting objects to Barnt Green homes plan

Packed meeting objects to Barnt Green homes plan

-

More than 100 people crammed into the Friends Meeting House, Barnt Green, to hear how the parish council planned to respond to proposals for as many as 200 new homes on a field on the edge of the village.

The proposed minimum of 98 homes are included in a Bromsgrove District Council document looking for places to allocate 4,000 new homes over the next ten years.

They would be built on a “Development Site”, for which the large fields behind the Barnt Green Inn would be earmarked.

A number of people at the meeting urged residents to come up with a “Plan B”, rather than rejecting the proposal completely.

But the atmosphere of the room was one of disbelief that anyone could consider any sort of development on one of the last green fields between Barnt Green and Cofton Hackett, which has already found itself joined to Birmingham.

Barnt Green Parish Council Chairman Judith Jagger said: “We are very concerned at the plan. This site is a prominent entry into Barnt Green next to the Barnt Green Inn, a Grade II listed building. It would be on the boundary of Lickey Country Park, next to a conservation area.

“We are opposed to this and have decided to organise a co-ordinated response.

“We have consulted a planning barrister, who is the son of one of our councillors and who is kindly giving his services for free. He recommended we employ a planning consultant.

“There will be a cost in preparing our defence. We might be tapping you up for a bit of cash to pay for it.

“But first, we hope the majority of parishioners will write to Bromsgrove District Council expressing your objections.”

Coun Susan Whitehand, the parish councillor with the planning brief, told the meeting: “Really it comes down to all of you and the amount of pressure we can put on the district council and the MP – I can’t see that they can ignore that.

“We are in the position at the moment where we are taking advice . . . which way to play it is not clear. But We would like it booted out altogether.

“The parish council, if you are agreed, can afford the first stage, but if it goes further we may have to come back to you.

“The barrister has said £50 per household would do the trick.”

With around 750 households in Barnt Green parish, that would come to around £37,500.

One resident said: “I am getting the impression that the parish is in some way battling against the authority to which we all pay our community charge?”

Coun Whitehand replied: “There is obviously a move to decentralise and allow local people to make some decisions. Unfortunately, that means district councillors and not parish councillors.”

District councillor Richard Deeming said: “I shall go with the vote of the people; if you vote against it, I will go with you.”

Another district councillor, Ann Doyle, pointed out: “We should be aware that we aren’t just one area that’s being targeted. Just about every part of Bromsgrove district has been allocated some sort of housing. Hagley are fighting 200 to 250 homes tooth and nail.

“There will be areas all over Bromsgrove fighting not to have these 4,000 houses that we have been told by the Government that we have got to have.”

She added: “I think we have to decide to say no, but we also have to decide on a very robust plan B. I think saying ‘no’ is almost not an option. I think we should go for a damage limitation exercise.

“We should all start to think what, in an ideal world, we want on that site. Certainly say ‘no’ and put up £50 per household for the consultant, but we should also have a plan B.”

But Coun Whitehand said: “If we start going into Plan Bs, we are just going to start muddying the water.”

To which Coun Doyle replied: “But then we may just get a development imposed upon us.”

Coun Whitehand referred to a planning appeal and High Court judgment over the land in 2004, which led to it being taken out of the Green Belt and designated so-called ‘white land’.

“According to our barrister the High Court judgment doesn’t establish allocation of the site,” she said.

“There is not established the principle that this should be a development site. So we are in a slightly stronger position and it may give us greater grounds for protesting.

Brian Fuller, a former district councillor and planning chairman in 2004 at the time of the High Court action, told the meeting: “I objected to it then. I thought it was a very perverse judgment that the district council takes it out of the Green Belt and it becomes white land.”

But he urged caution over an outright rejection of any development on the site, saying it would be safer to suggest an alternative use.

“We should think up an alternative use, such as the possibility of putting a new school on the site and using it as a joint community venture. You have then got the school site for developing, which is just what they did in Alvechurch.

“That kind of proposal would not be unreasonably treated by the district council. By saying ‘no’ you are forcing them to make a decision and they will be wary of the cost of an appeal.

“The reality is there must be another 4,000 houses and they have to go somewhere. I don’t think putting houses on that site is the answer, but putting something else there may be.”

One resident questioned why there should be a need for 4,000 homes in Bromgrove, especially bearing in mind the development at the former Longbridge motor site.

“We are just over the hill from one of the biggest development sites in Europe, so why do we need more houses here?” he asked.

Another Barnt Green resident, Cecil Buckett, said: “People are talking about 98 homes, but , but it could be a lot more than that. Don’t anyone go away with the feeling that there are only going to be 98.”

Coun Whitehand said: “We are meeting Banner Homes [thought to be a potential developer of the site] next week and will see what they are proposing. The problem is that this will be an outline planning application, which only says ‘this is where we are starting, actually, not where we are ending up’.”

Coun Doyle pointed out that 40 per cent of the homes are supposed to be affordable, to which one villager said, to a round of applause: “I don’t see this area as one for first-time buyers. I lived in Rednal and my aspiration was to get into Barnt Green. If you can’t afford to live in Barnt Green, tough!”

Winding up the meeting, Coun Whitehand told the residents: “My feeling is that you should voice your objections as strongly as you can. The more people who do that, the more we can negotiate. I think by April 15, the parish council is going to have to make up its mind to go down the one route.”

Barnt Green public meeting

New homes in ‘Core Strategy’

The Village View