HomeFeaturesfinanceMaintain with-profit funds with caution

Maintain with-profit funds with caution

-

ADVERTISEMENT FEATURE

Terry Reed says we should be aware of fund changes.

Historically, with-profit funds have held great appeal among cautious investors wishing to avoid the ups and downs of stock market investment.

And for many years these funds performed well, thanks to insurance companies prudently setting aside some of the growth earned in good years to subsidise lesser years, where investment returns proved poor.

Unfortunately, however, their prudence was pushed to one side during the bull stock market run of the 1990s. Higher and higher bonuses were paid, as it seemed the good times would never end, particularly once the technology boom took hold.

Finally in 2000, the bubble burst. Three years of negative returns followed, a record pretty well unprecedented in the history of the stock market. The bad times had returned with a vengeance, as there were now insufficient reserves to ride out such poor market conditions.

If investors wished to surrender their with-profits policy, heavy penalties applied, which were known as market value adjustments or MVAs.

As a consequence the with-profits industry has declined over recent years, in parallel with plummeting annual bonuses. In 2000 the industry saw £15 billion in investments; in 2005 this had fallen to a mere £1.5 billion.

While markets appear to have recovered, many insurance companies are expected to announce minimal or no bonus as they continue to rebuild their reserves. Even today, some are continuing to apply MVA penalties.

While investments across the board have suffered from falling long-term returns, with-profit funds have had to endure the additional burdens of endowment shortfalls, changes in the asset mix of many funds, bad press, regulatory changes and closing funds.

Furthermore, with-profit funds have had their exposure to equities dramatically reduced, and since equities hold the most potential for achieving higher returns in the long-term, this has drastically reduced the growth potential of with-profit.

Due to the radical changes in the underlying structure of with-profit funds, it is advisable for those who hold such investments, whether as part of their pension plan or in an investment bond as part of their personal wealth portfolio, to seek independent financial advice and establish the propriety of maintaining such a fund.

Terry Reed is Technical Director at AFH Independent Financial Services Ltd in Bromsgrove. You can contact AFH on 01527 577775 for advice on a range of investment matters – initial consultation without charge or obligation.