HomeFeaturesfinanceWhat a pantomime!

What a pantomime!

-

ADVERTISEMENT FEATURE

Austin Broad tells a story of woe that could have ended so differently . . .

This is an example of how trying to do the right thing without the proper advice can lead to unforeseen outcomes . . .

Widow Twankey had two sons, Delboy and Rodney. The widow had been killed in unfortunate circumstances in a laundry accident and her sensible son Rodney was in the process of applying for probate.

He was fairly relaxed about the process because even though the widow’s husband had used all his nil rate band on his death many years earlier, he had calculated that his mother’s assets only came to £300,000 in value and he knew that the current nil rate band was £325,000.

Rodney’s confidence however, proved to be misplaced.

Just over five years before the widow’s death, Delboy, the tearaway son, had decided to leave home to set up house with Mother Goose. He had negotiated an agreement between his mother and his brother that he should receive his share of the inheritance now and be written out of the widow’s will.

After much discussion, it was agreed that he should receive £250,000, which fortunately the widow was able to raise easily.

The will was changed, leaving all of her estate to her son Rodney and everybody went about their business as usual and the widow, being a very generous sort, had regularly used up her annual exemptions making gifts to her sons.

When Rodney went to his adviser to discuss the estate and his future inheritance, he was visibly shocked when he was told that rather than receiving the £300,000 he was expecting, he would receive only £210,000, which was less than his brother the tearaway had received five years earlier.

He was told that the gift that the widow made to Delboy was classed as a Potentially Exempt Transfer and not therefore immediately exempt.

While there was no immediate charge to Inheritance Tax, the widow would have had to live for seven years for the gift to fall outside of the estate.

As she had died five years ago, the Potentially Exempt Transfer had now become a Chargeable Transfer. This in itself was not a problem, as it was within the nil rate band of £325,000 and therefore would not create a tax liability.

However, it had the effect of using up and reducing the £325,000 nil rate band available for use on the rest of the estate leaving only £75,000.

As the estate was valued by Rodney at £300,000, this did mean that the Inheritance Tax was chargeable on the balance of the estate (i.e. £300,000 – £75,000 = £225,000).

As the tax was payable at 40% the Inheritance Tax payable was £90,000 meaning that Rodney would only receive £210,000.

Rodney was distraught, but visibly brightened when he thought he had discovered a loophole in the advice from his adviser.

Rodney had read that Taper Relief was available dependent upon when during the seven year period the death had occurred. He had read that on death within the first three years, no relief was available, but that on death in subsequent years relief was available at 20%, 40%, 60% and finally 80% on death in the seventh year following the death.

By Rodney’s calculation this would mean that the tax liability would be reduced from £90,000 to £36,000 (allowing 60% relief as death was in the 5th year following the gift) and at £264,000 this would be a much more equitable outcome compared to the above.

Rodney’s relief was only short-lived however, when he was informed by his adviser that while he was correct in his belief that taper relief existed, it would not apply in this case, as it only applies where there was an Inheritance Tax liability on the gift made.

In this case, because the gift was within the allowable nil rate band, the relief (60% on the tax liability on the gift) was 60% on zero.

Rodney was crushed and felt no better when the adviser informed him that had he taken advice at the time the gift was agreed, a simple solution involving a seven year level term assurance, written subject to a suitable trust, could have been recommended at negligible cost.*

* Professional adviser – 31st January 2013. ‘Inheritance tax and the prodigal son’

The content of this article is generic and should not be construed as specific investment advice. Please contact us before proceeding with any course of action.

AFH Wealth Management is a trading style of AFH Independent Financial Services Limited, which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Services Authority.

For more details or to sign up for the AFH e-newsletter, visit https://www.afhwm.co.uk

Austin Broad is Technical Director at AFH Wealth Management.