Make sure you are aware of all the options, writes Terry Reed.
It is a sad fact that almost half of all marriages end in divorce, and of course this means that an agreement, either amicable or as laid down by a court, has to be made regarding all accrued assets.
An important part of the consideration is often pension benefits, which for some is the second most valuable asset after the family home. The difficulty in deciding what will happen to pension benefits lies in the fact that there are a number of options, and also that various Governments over the years have made pension legislation so complex.
The result of this is that there are some traps for the unwary to fall into, and in our experience some solicitors are not aware of these. This means that anyone who has to include pension benefits in their divorce settlement should seek independent financial advice as well as a good divorce lawyer.
My examples assume a wife is being awarded a share of her husband’s pension pot. I accept this could easily be the other way around. I have done this purely for the sake of ease rather than to make a sexist comment!
Offsetting
This is the longest established way of dealing with things, namely the pension is valued and the spouse has other assets in lieu.
For example, say the house is valued at £200,000 and husband’s pension is also £200,000. It might be agreed that the spouse has the home and the husband gets to keep his pension.
Whilst this provides a clean break, the problem is that there are often insufficient assets to allow such an easy split – for example, how do you put down a deposit on a new house if all your money is in a pension you can’t access until you are 60?
Earmarking Orders
These have been used fairly often in the past but are not usually now recommended. The court might draw up an order saying, for example, that when the husband draws his pension, 50 per cent will be paid direct to his ex-spouse by the pension office.
The problem here is that the spouse will not be able to choose when to draw her share of the pension benefits, as the options remain with the husband. You can imagine what might happen where a divorce is far from amicable.
The latest that a pension can be delayed by an unhappy husband is his 75th birthday. Secondly, the pension is taxed as though it were the husband’s, so if he is paying 40% tax, this is deducted at source and his spouse cannot reclaim this, even if she is a non-tax payer!
Finally, such sharing orders become invalid if the spouse re-marries.
Pension Splitting
This is often the best option, as the spouse is given a percentage of the ex husband’s pension. It does not have to be 50% – it could be more or less; in fact it could be as much as 100%, depending on other circumstances.
With this option the pension is transferred to the spouse and held by her in her own name, so for example if the husband’s pension pot is valued at £200,000 she might be awarded £100,000.
She will have control of where to invest the money (a new policy will need to be arranged unless she is allowed to become a member of the existing pension scheme) and, most importantly, what age to draw benefits.
Pension income will be taxed at her marginal rate, and she will have the full range of options at retirement, buy an annuity, use a “drawdown” plan, etc.
Tax Free Cash
One of the key advantages of a pension plan for many people is that at retirement there is a tax-free cash sum available, though recently the Government has changed the name of this to the Pension Commencement Lump Sum, indicating that it may not always be tax free!
This will usually be 25% of the accrued fund and might be particularly useful to a divorced spouse with few other savings. But watch out for the trap below:
Protected & Safeguarded Rights
Protected Rights is the pension built up over the years from National Insurance rebates.
As this has come from the Government, they have applied special rules to these benefits over the years, and the net result is that they are less flexible than an ordinary pension.
In certain circumstances on transfers from Final Salary schemes the whole fund (which includes money not accrued from National Insurance rebates) becomes known as Safeguarded Rights. Safeguarded Rights have some potentially disastrous pitfalls, caused because the Government has managed to miss them out from recent legislation.
For example they do not allow a pension commencement lump sum (tax-free or otherwise!) to be drawn at all, whereas Protected Rights does. Not only this, but benefits cannot be drawn until age 60, whereas Protected Rights can currently be taken from age 50.
Although the Government is now aware of these discrepancies it may be some years before they are corrected. In these circumstances a spouse should seek other pension assets if there are any, or leave the pension for the husband and go for the Offsetting option instead.
I hope my message is clear: don’t get divorced, but if you do, get advice, and don’t expect your solicitor to know all the answers!
Terry Reed is Technical Director at AFH Independent Financial Services in Bromsgrove.
Tel: 01527 577775.
