HomeNewsenvironmentSix more months of lorries for Lickeys

Six more months of lorries for Lickeys

-

The new 'reservoir'

Lickey and Marlbrook residents have been plunged back into the “nightmare” of heavy lorries thundering past their homes to dump yet more material on to the Lickey Hills.

This is in spite of the owner of the former Marlbrook Tip having already overtipped one million tons on the site, according to Bromsgrove District Council.

The council failed to heed warnings of overtipping from residents for years but had pledged to take enforcement action to improve the site.

It is now accused of hiding behind a smokescreen provided by the Environment Agency, which is telling the owner to carry out the recommendations of a specialist “panel” engineer to make a reservoir on the site safe.

This means possibly six more months of lorries to bring on enough “restoration soil” to create a layer 300mm deep over most of the site.

Residents were told at a public meeting that the panel engineer recommending the work was accredited by the Government and appointed by the site owner.

Many in the room backed calls for a public inquiry into the “mess” and this was to be debated at Bromsgrove’s full council meeting as The Village went to press.

More than 100 people attended the public meeting at Lickey Parish Hall to hear Bromsgrove planning chief Ruth Bamford explain: “While we were beavering away working on the enforcement notice, we stumbled across complex issues, including the Reservoirs Act and the panel engineer’s report.”

She explained that an area of the tip (pictured above) was large enough to be classified as a “reservoir” and the engineer had said more material had to be brought on to make it safe.

“We found ourselves in potential conflict with the panel engineer’s recommendations,” added Ms Bamford. “We have to allow the panel engineer’s safety requirements to take priority, which means we can’t do what we aspire to do.”

Depending on the size of the lorries and how much they carried, it could take 140 lorries a week for six months to bring on the material, said Ms Bamford.

“Some people have suggested the owner might make a profit. Whether he makes a profit or a loss is immaterial.”

An Environment Agency officer, Fiona Upchurch, told the meeting that a panel engineer was a prestigious appointment: “There are only about 20 on the panel – they are picked by Defra.”

But one resident asked: “Would a different panel engineer come up with a different solution?”

Ms Upchurch said: “I’m not a panel engineer. I enforce what a panel engineer recommends. If he says there needs to be a certain amount of soil on the top of this site, then that’s what I will work on and that’s what I’ll enforce.”

She also confirmed monitoring of the work would be carried out by the panel engineer, or his representative, as the engineer who had made the recommendation was based in Edinburgh.

Ms Upchurch added: “Apparently, the owner is applying for planning permission to do the work on the site.”

One member of the public, who described himself as a former parish councillor, an engineer and a Lickey resident, said: “The reservoir is an artificial situation. It is a tiny puddle and it wasn’t there before. You are hiding behind the reservoir – it isn’t a reservoir, it should be a stream.”

Roy Hughes, a resident who tried to raise the alarm about overtipping long before the council stepped in, said: “I am really quite astounded that a little pond has been elevated to being a reservoir.”

County councillor Peter McDonald said: “How can anyone have any confidence when the Environment Agency is being used as a smokescreen by the district council? I hope councillors present here tonight will join us in asking for a public inquiry.”

A resident joined the call: “I think this meeting was intended to reassure the public, but it has left us more worried. We agree with Coun McDonald that there should be a public inquiry because this is a mess.”

Another resident said: “No one has any confidence this is going to be sorted out. We have been here before.

“Why has a council’s opinion been trumped by a panel engineer’s opinion?

“This is why we need a public inquiry to get to the bottom of this.”

See The Village View