An application to build 22 new homes in Hopwood – considered highly speculative because the site is protected by the Green Belt – was deferred last night after Alvechurch councillor Roger Hollingworth gave it his support.
If the plans for the field on the east side of Hopwood roundabout were to be approved, it would blow a hole in the Green Belt around our villages.
According to reports from the Bromsgrove planning committee meeting, council officers had voiced their opposition and recommended refusal of the plans before Coun Hollingworth – who is the leader of Bromsgrove Council and a former parish councillor for Hopwood – backed their approval.
Alvechurch parish councillors, who voiced opposition at last night’s meeting, later told The Village that Coun Hollingworth had stressed the condition of the site and the fact there is permission to use it for storage as reasons to approve the housing plans.
He is also said to have urged the committee not to wait for the outcome of a Green Belt review, due to decide if any sites currently protected could be used for housing after 2023, and that he believed if Bromsgrove rejected the plans a planning inspector would approve them on appeal.
His intervention, which carries weight because of his position on the district council, came as a surprise to some of those present, particularly because Hopwood is currently within the Alvechurch Ward he represents at Bromsgrove (Hopwood is due to be joined to Barnt Green to form a new district council ward).
As Green Belt, there have to be very special circumstances to allow any activity that affects the openness of the site. A development close by in Hopwood five years ago was only allowed because the whole development was of affordable homes – and even then it was highly controversial and led to a reprimand for Bromsgrove from the Ombudsman.
Even though planning officers had reported to the committee last night that the licence for storage use did not allow any buildings on the site and so it remained open Green Belt, the committee eventually asked them to investigate the site’s status again and report back.
Alvechurch Parish Council chairman Andy Humphries, who was at the meeting, said it looked likely the application would come back before the committee next month.
In the meantime, the parish council would be carrying out its own urgent investigation – particularly into why officers had not prevented the dumping of rubble on the site – “making it look more brownfield than greenfield” – in recent years despite being asked to take enforcement action by the parish council.
The council did investigate “unauthorised development”, namely “Tarmac and groundworks” at the site as recently as this year. According the council documents, the investigating officer closed the case for a “technical reason or duplication”.
The same officer investigated “laying of hardcore on field” at the site in 2010, but decided to not take the “unauthorised breach of control” any further because it was “not expedient to pursue” the matter.
There would be a public outcry if planning committee members now decided to allow housing on a Green Belt field even partly because their council had failed to enforce its own planning policy.
The Village has contacted Coun Hollingworth for his comments.
The agenda item for last night’s meeting, including the officer’s reason for refusing the application, can be seen here:
https://moderngovwebpublic.bromsgrove.gov.uk/documents/s22005/Application%2012%201040%20-%20Land%20rear%20of%201-6%20Smedley%20Crooke%20Place%20Redditch%20Road%20Hopwood.pdf
The documents and comments related to the application can be seen here:
https://appuview.bromsgrove.gov.uk/online-applications/applicationDetails.do?activeTab=makeComment&keyVal=MEXB81DP3S000
