
A vital 12 acres of green fields close to the centre of Barnt Green may have become a planning “black hole” after a High Court decision went against Bromsgrove District Council.
As The Village went to press there was confusion over what the ruling actually means for the land around the Barnt Green Inn. It appears, however, that its status is now in limbo – neither clear-cut Green Belt nor earmarked for future development.
Villagers have pledged they would fight the “appalling” idea of more than 200 homes being built there, which would mean the end of Barnt Green as they know it.
Their fears date back to May 2002 when a Government inspector earmarked the fields as an ADR – an “Area of Development Restraint”, which puts Green Belt land at risk of development.
More than 1,500 people voiced their opposition and Bromsgrove council heeded their opinions by rejecting the inspector’s recommendation for the site when it adopted its Local Plan for the area in January this year.
But the owner of the land challenged the council’s actions in the High Court last month, where a judge ruled the council should have given stronger reasons for its decision.
What is still to be decided is what this means for the site. Bromsgrove head of local plans Paul Crysell told The Village: “I am awaiting a written verdict from our barrister. My understanding is that the judge was asked to look at the argument we made for rejecting the site as a long-term development site and his conclusion was that our arguments were not strong enough and so he quashed our decision to ignore the inspector.”
But the judge did not have the power to make the council include the site as an ADR.
“We have a site that’s a black hole almost,” said Mr Crysell. “If someone came along with a planning application for some use for it, I suggest that we would reject it and then argue the case in front of another inspector.”
He stressed that this was still his interpretation, but said his department was already wondering how to show the land in the Local Plan when it is published this summer.
Depending on legal advice, the council would have a number of options, including taking the case to the Court of Appeal. But Mr Crysell said: “I think that would be a grave misjudgment because I think it could repeat the ruling and the costs would be horrendous.”
The council could just leave the land in limbo or it could address it in the next plan, to be called the Local Development Framework and due to be completed by March 2007.
Barnt Green Parish chairman Elaine Buckett told The Village she was also awaiting more information, but she restated the village’s opposition to any kind of development of the site.
“People would be appalled. There would be a lot of reaction, and not just from Barnt Green, but from the 1,500 people who signed the petition.
“We would protest as much as we could and make sure that the people were able to make their voices heard.”
Coun Buckett added: “If we had to put some more houses in Barnt Green, that would be the last place to put them because it’s the last visual barrier between us and Birmingham.
“And no town or village can absorb another one-third growth. Another 250 units on top of 700 units is a dramatic increase. The school would have to move and if the school moves, the heart of the village is gone and Barnt Green as it is, as an active, vibrant village, would change forever.”
