ADVERTISEMENT FEATURE
Tax in retirement can make a big difference, writes Terry Reed.
An advantage of being an Independent Financial Adviser is that not only can we pick from the best products available in the whole market place, but we can also tell our clients when something is not suitable at all…
We are all urged by the Government to put money into pensions, but this is because they fear those who don’t will become a burden on the State.
In fact, I think anyone would agree that putting money aside is a sensible thing to do – but is a pension plan the best place to put it? This relies very much on your circumstances.
Firstly, pension plans benefit from tax relief, so if you put £1,000 into a policy, the plan provider will add on 22% tax relief so that £1,282 is invested. If you are a higher rate tax payer, further tax relief can be obtained, and on £1,282 this would be £230.
A comparable investment plan would be an Individual Savings Account (ISA) because, like a pension plan, this grows without the deduction of any further tax – although both pension and ISA managers are not able to reclaim the tax deducted on dividends – but no tax relief is given at source, so £1,000 paid in by an investor remains as £1,000.
Now the policy grows to retirement, let us say a period of 20 years. A net investment of £1,000 each year, achieving 7% growth per annum net of any charges, would leave the pension plan with a fund of £62,556 compared to £40,995 in the ISA.
To get the pension fund, a basic rate tax payer has paid in £20,000, a higher rate tax payer only £15,384.80. The ISA investor has paid in £20,000, but his fund value is smaller. But what happens next?
Pension plans offer a tax free cash sum, but only 25% of the accrued fund can be taken this way, in this case £15,639. There is frequent speculation that this benefit may be taken away at some point in the future. On the other hand the whole ISA fund, £40,995, can be taken as a tax-free lump sum.
Of course, the main reason to set up a pension plan is that people need an income when they retire and ISAs can also give income, but there is a difference. Pension income is subject to tax at your marginal rate, whereas ISA income is tax-free.
Assuming that 5% income is taken, the following shows the net position after tax from the whole available fund:
Pension Plan ISA
Gross income £3,127.80 £2,049.75
@ 5%
Net income after £2,439.76 £2,049.75
basic rate tax
Net income after £1,251.12 £2,049.75
higher rate tax
As you can see, the pension is slightly higher for a basic rate tax payer, but worse for someone who pays higher rate.
Of course, in retirement a higher rate tax payer may revert to paying basic rate, because their income may fall to that level. People in these circumstances will benefit the most.
But there is a catch. It is the Government’s speculation that if it gives tax relief on a pension plan then it should also set rules about how benefits are taken – for example, the fund is not yours to do with as you wish.
To explain, apart from the tax-free cash, you cannot pass the whole fund to children. If you die before age 75 the fund is taxed at 35%; if you die after age 75 the pension fund suffers massive charges, with some calculating this to be as high as 82%. In this case, when passing on inheritance, children will benefit most if their parents die before 75.
On the other hand, the whole ISA fund can be disposed of as you wish, though Inheritance Tax at 40% might be due for those with an estate of more than £300,000.
Such a large estate is not unusual, with property prices being so high, but there are several things you can do to reduce Inheritance Tax and it is advisable to make the most of your tax allowance.
There are some who will benefit more from pension plans, namely those who have an employer who will pay into a plan for them as part of a company pension, since this additional benefit is not subject to tax or National Insurance.
There may be a sting in the tail for some lower paid individuals because under current rules they may find their benefits in retirement are cut if they have pension income. People with small pension funds may be able to take a lump sum instead of a pension.
Those who may benefit most from a pension may also be those who run their own companies, since substantial amounts can now be paid in, again without corporation tax, income tax or National Insurance.
Think carefully before you decide which way to go, and take advice.
Terry Reed is Technical Director at AFH Independent Financial Services Ltd in Bromsgrove: 01527 577775.