HomeNewsBromsgroveOmbudsman raps council over homes approval

Ombudsman raps council over homes approval

-

Bromsgrove District Council has been hauled over the coals by the Local Government Ombudsman for the way it approved plans for affordable homes in Hopwood.

The Ombudsman, Jerry White, said there had been maladministration by the council causing injustice. In his report, Mr White says: “I do not believe that they gave the application the careful consideration that was due to it, especially when officer advice was clear that permission should have been refused.”

A complaint was made on behalf of a residents’ committee that the council did not properly consider an application for 20 affordable homes “in the Green Belt, adjacent to a hamlet of around 60 homes”.

In his report, the Ombudsman said residents had submitted a petition opposing the development to a local councillor, but the councillor had not passed this to the council.

To demonstrate local need for affordable housing, the council had submitted a survey of housing need in the wider parish, some data about average house prices and incomes in the area, and information from the council’s housing register.

The council’s planning manager had recommended that the council refuse the application because the development did not meet local or national planning policy.

The Ombudsman found that council members:
• Failed to distinguish between housing need and housing demand;
• Took an irrelevant factor into account in assessing harm to the Green Belt;
• Failed to give adequate consideration to officer advice about protected tree cover, and to Natural England’s advice about possible habitats for protected species on the site; and
• Failed to give adequate reasons for approving the application.

The Ombudsman concluded the development was open to members to approve, but objectors were left with “a degree of understandable outrage that the council should have handled matters better, and had to take time and trouble in pursuing the complaint”. He said the council should pay the complainant £1,000.

Chairman of the Planning Committee, Coun Ted Tibby, told The Village: “The lack of affordable housing is an issue in this district, and remains so – however we accept the Ombudsman’s decision on this matter, and we take on board all the findings of the report.”