Plans for a rendering plant at Hopwood moved a step closer when a Government inspector gave the go-ahead for a 17 metre chimney on the site.
This means the owners of Mayfield Farm can now ask Bromsgrove District Council to issue a pollution prevention and control licence to allow the proposed plant to process around 85 tonnes per day of animal waste.
The decision by Brian Sims follows a three-day public inquiry at Bromsgrove in Ferbruary which saw a large number of protesters expressing fears about the plans, as reported last month in The Village magazine.
Despite written objections from around 1,000 people and protests by a number of local bodies and the MP, Julie Kirkbride, the inspector said he had to make his decision based purely on planning considerations.
In his decision, he explains that the extent to which the question of potential pollution from the operation bears upon planning matters is restricted.
“The main public concerns surrounding this proposal for a new chimney to serve existing lawful development in practice relate to bad past experience of alleged pollution from Mayfield Farm and fears that it will worsen if the chimney is permitted,” he said.
But he had to work on the assumption that the pollution prevention and control regime would be effective in ensuring the rendering plant complied with legal limits.
“I repect the undoubtedly genuine fear and distrust among many hundreds of local objectors who are dependent on PPC controls to protect them in the face of their past experiences of Mayfield Farm,” he said.
“However, case law is clear that where such matters are regulated by the other statutory code, public fear must be supported by positive evidence in order to be regarded as an overriding material planning consideration.
“I am not persuaded that such planning evidence exists in this case and therefore can only ascribe limited planning weight to the public anxiety widely expressed at the inquiry, including for the local MP and extensive fishing, sailing and hotel business interests that were strongly expressed.
“Overall, I consider there to be no planning objection to the proposed chimney with respect to odour and other emissions.”
Mr Sims also decided that noise and traffic fears were also not grounds for objection to the plan.
At the same time there was a need for the chimney so that Mayfield Farm could run a thermal oxidiser to reduce odour from the rendering process and the diversification of Mayfield Farm would support the rural economy and provide four extra jobs.
The chimney would cause “slight harm” to the openness of the green belt, but the need for the chimney amounted to the “very special circumstances” required under planning law to allow it to be built.
Mr Sims said the new chimney could not be built until the existing one had been removed and its colour and finish had to be approved by the county council.
