How our District Council has gone from ‘worst ever’ to the threshold of being praised as ‘good’ – Council Leader Roger Hollingworth tells Richard Peach what Bromsgrove has done to get back on track.

‘You are the worst council in the country . . . ” The words of the Government Minister settled like a dark cloud on the group from Bromsgrove.
Then, the story goes, the head of the Whitehall local government intervention division, who was also at the meeting, leant over to pass more information to the Minister, Angela Smith.
Ms Smith digested it, looked back towards the group and told them: “I’ve been corrected; you are the worst council we’ve ever seen.”
They knew it would be bad, but to be the “worst ever” was a shock to those summoned to the Department for Communities and Local Government in London, including Bromsgrove District Council leader Roger Hollingworth.
He can afford a smile now, retelling the tale in the less chilly surroundings of his council office, but it was clearly not a pleasant experience.
“The Conservatives will say it was just the Labour Government telling us that, but I think it was right. I think we were the worst in the country,” admits Coun Hollingworth. “If you look at the performance indicators, 85 per cent of ours were below average and 35 per cent were in free fall.”
Coun Hollingworth continues the story: “This was July 2006 and Angela Smith said, ‘I want to see you in November and if it hasn’t improved we will have to see what we can do’.”
They managed to persuade her to give them another couple of months, until February 2007, then headed back to the Midlands to try to turn things round.
The council had already been in “voluntary engagement” with the Government since June 2004, which meant its every move was being monitored and it was under notice to improve, or else.
The “else” was clearly very close two summers ago and could have led to the Government taking over and “members [the councillors] being put into the car park”, according to Coun Hollingworth.
Who knows what this would have meant for the services provided to the people and businesses of Bromsgrove district?
“We had made no progress and it was a farce,” says Coun Hollingworth, giving as an example the council’s lack of a human resources department for an organisation with more than 450 employees.
He had taken over as leader in November 2005 after being elected to the council in May 2003, when he had almost immediately been invited to join the ruling Conservative Cabinet, first in charge of introducing wheelie bins before taking control of Bromsgrove’s finances and resources.
In the latter role, he worked closely with Kevin Dicks, the officer who had recently been recruited as head of resources. It was a relationship that was to prove fruitful.
“We just gelled,” says Coun Hollingworth. “We each seemed to know what the other was thinking.”
Gradually they got the accounts under control and when the council chief executive role required filling in May 2006, with Coun Hollingworth by then the council leader, he naturally wanted Mr Dicks for the job.
Only weeks into the top job – and still with the title “acting” Chief Executive – Mr Dicks had been among the group to be given Angela Smith’s ultimatum.
Eight months later, when he and the others returned to London in February 2007 the reception, recalls Coun Hollingworth, was a good deal more cordial.
Beforehand, the Bromsgrove party was given a parliamentary tour by MP Julie Kirkbride, who then accompanied them to where the meeting was to take place.
“The atmosphere was totally different,” says Coun Hollingworth. “Angela Smith actually invited Julie Kirkbride to stay in the meeting. So this was a Labour Minister inviting a Conservative MP to sit in on a meeting, although Julie wasn’t actually able to take up the offer.”
The reason for the warm reception was that the Bromsgrove team had pulled it off; they had shown sufficient progress to be allowed to continue guiding the council back to health – and Kevin Dicks could lose the “acting” from his job title.
“From appointing Kevin in May, until February the next year, we got ourselves out of trouble – that’s how quickly we did it,” says Coun Hollingworth.
The process involved bringing to a local authority his experience from many successful years getting the most out of businesses in “the real world”.
“Up until we took control, the members were trying to do the officers’ jobs. I stopped members getting involved and I said to the officers, ‘we will tell you what we want and you will deliver it’.
“We created the environment in which the officers could work, but the credit has to go to Kevin and his officers for delivering it.
“What they do is not always what I would do, but so long as they are delivering what we want, that is fine.”
This was a management lesson Coun Hollingworth had learned way back in the days of British Leyland when he and a colleague, faced with a tricky decision with wide implications, went to seek the advice of their chairman, Sir Michael Edwardes.
After travelling all the way down to London, the meeting lasted barely two minutes. “Sir Michael said, ‘You are the managers – do you have a plan B in case it goes wrong? And if it does go wrong, don’t make the same mistake twice.’” He then despatched them back to the Midlands.
“At Bromsgrove now, I keep the members out of the officers’ hair. We have created an environment for them in the way Sir Michael Edwardes did for me.”
“We have supported the officers totally. I have never criticised an officer in public and if they do something I support them.
“They all know they are allowed to make mistakes so long as they do not make the same one twice. The officers really have turned it around for us.”
The council is so confident of its improvement that it has told the Audit Commission it is ready to be reassessed at any time.
Mr Dicks has written to the commission setting out the council’s improvements since its previous Comprehensive Performance Assessment last year which ranked the council as “poor”.
It now believes it will achieve a “good” rating.
Mr Dicks said: “This council has become more focused on our priorities by listening to residents and investing in those areas that are important to them.
“We are better at managing our finances and, following the external feedback that we have received recently, the time seems right to ask for a re-inspection.”
If the request is given the go-ahead by the Audit Commission, inspectors could be expected at the Council House as early as November. Meanwhile, Coun Hollingworth believes that residents should already be starting to see improvement.
“As we have got on top of the organisation we are looking at the services,” he explains. “If you look at litter, only 65 per cent of our roads came up to the standards set by the Government. Now it is 85 per cent.
“We are working now to get to the point where if someone complains about litter within 24 hours we will sort it out.
“We don’t get as many complaints about ground maintenance now and we have a refuse collection system which is 50th in the country out of more than 300 councils.
“Residents should see an improvement in tidiness and cleanliness of their areas. For example, we are now picking up the litter before we cut the grass so we don’t just shred it at the side of the road.”
Coun Hollingworth said people should also see an improvement in safety because they were working very closely with the police.
“And we are working closely with the youth to tackle anti-social behaviour,” he went on. The MUGA [new multi-use play equipment] in Alvechurch is a perfect example.
“We will start to provide more affordable housing. The drive for this is coming from the council because we want to get the mix right. If we don’t get the affordable housing, all the youngsters will leave and only older people will come into Bromsgrove.

“On planning, we want to make sure that everyone knows that if they speak to their ward councillor then we will either fight their corner or tell them straight that they have no chance.
“I am also trying to spread spending to the villages – that’s what we are trying to do by introducing sports hubs. We don’t want all the money poured into the town – although now I’m getting criticised for pumping too much money into Alvechurch!”
Some decisions, however, are bound to be unpopular, although Coun Hollingworth is ready to take the brickbats. Withdrawing free parking for pensioners in Bromsgrove town centre has upset some very vocal groups, but he is unrepentant.
“We stopped the cheap parking when the Government introduced national travel for pensioners, which we have estimated is going to cost us about £200,000.”
Similarly, there have been complaints about the withdrawal of free green waste collections next year, although Coun Hollingworth points out that we don’t hear from the people who will be pleased they won’t in future be paying for a service they don’t use.
“As a Conservative council we are looking to charge for as many services as we can so that people can choose which they want to use, and then we can bring the council tax down,” he explains.
“The fact that I came from the private sector, from a business background, is what made the big difference. It is not that I am a Conservative, you get good businessmen who are Labour supporters.
“Where the politics come in is that we want to give people the choice of where to spend their money and not tell them, ‘you will spend it on this’.”
What do you think?
Have you noticed things getting better in your area? What else could still be done? Write or email your views, good or bad, to us.
ROGER’S ROAD TO LEADERSHIP
‘Why do I do it? Because I have had a good living out of society and I wanted to put something back in.”
And, Roger Hollingworth could have added, it’s certainly not for the money: as Leader of Bromsgrove District Council, working the equivalent of a full-time job and putting in unsociable hours at evening meetings and weekend engagements, he says he receives around £15,000 a year.
Now 63, Roger retired as managing director of a Redditch-based AT&T Istel subsidiary in 1991 aged 45.
“When I retired I didn’t plan on doing anything after that. I just wanted some freedom to do something I wanted to do, but after a while I got bored.
“I wanted to be a vet and I tried to retrain, but the only college I could get into was in America – everywhere in the UK said I was too old – but my wife didn’t want to go to the States.
“So the next best thing was to buy a farm and some sheep” [this was in Rowney Green, where Roger still lives with wife Jacqueline].
He continued using his business experience as a consultant to a number of companies, helping to turn around their fortunes, but eventually tired of the transatlantic travel.
“In the end I thought, ‘I don’t want to do this any more’.”
It was around this time, towards the end of 1997, that he joined Alvechurch Parish Council, becoming chairman a year later.
“I’d kept complaining about things and John Puckering [another Rowney Green farmer and the current chairman of the parish council] asked me to join the council. My wife said, ‘why don’t you do something about it rather than just complaining?’”
But he found he was “banging his head against a wall” trying to get anything done at a parish level and resigned from the council in 2002.
“When I left the parish council I didn’t plan to go on the district council. It was June Griffiths [the ward councillor for Bordesley and now the deputy leader at Bromsgrove] who approached me and said, ‘I know the frustration you had at the parish council, but you can do something at Bromsgrove’.”
He was elected in May 2003 and became Leader in November 2005.
