I am writing in response to Rev David Martin’s article on marriage in the May 2012 edition of The Grapevine (parish magazine of St Laurence Church, Alvechurch http;//www.alvechurch-stlaurence.org).
The Rector begins with disclaimers intended to position his arguments as non-homophobic, stating he’s “numbered many homosexual men” as friends over the years. The inference being that, since I am friends with people in this minority group, I couldn’t possibly be prejudicial.
As for the main content of the article, Rev Martin describes homosexuality as a “condition”, a “phase”, and something that people “grow out of”. He implies that homosexuality is a clinical condition which can be “caused” following “psychological harm”.
Notwithstanding the lack of evidence for this, his public denouncement of homosexuality as a “sin” is an enormously retrograde step in a society that is trying to fight the last sanctuary of prejudice. If the Church is describing homosexuality as a sin, what message does this send to the playground, the football field and the office?
These are all domains where discrimination persists despite legislative intervention. These ill-considered sentiments are clearly counterproductive in this fight.
Imagine if I were to use the public platform afforded by my job to highlight how religion is a psychological condition and that, following the indoctrination of youth, many individuals grow out of this phase?
Indeed, if I were to encourage discrimination (albeit indirectly), I would most likely be made unemployed. I feel Rev Martin should be acutely aware of the responsibility that comes with the power of his office.
The Church has a lot of power in this country and can be a force for enormous good. However, in order to be taken seriously it must stop obsessing with the bedroom. Surely, the fact that two adults love each other is a wonderful thing?
The Rector appears to argue that legalising same-sex unions will send a confusing message to young people and may somehow bewilder them into becoming homosexual.
Sexuality is not a fashion (even if it were, it would not matter as long as adults were consenting), it is a fundamental part of an individual’s identity.
As a chap who has recently got married (to a woman, no less), I am acutely aware of how farcically patriarchal the process is. It’s outdated – as are Rev Martin’s views.
Perhaps he should focus his energies on reducing the pain and hate in the world by combating discrimination rather than perpetuating it.
Andy Johnson, Alvechurch
