HomeNewsenvironmentThe new Lickey Hill?

The new Lickey Hill?

-

An earth mover silhouetted on Marlbrook Tip

Villagers who blamed the ten-year “nightmare” of lorries thundering up the Lickey Hills on too much waste being taken to Marlbrook Tip appear to have been vindicated by a report of over-tipping on a vast scale.

More than one million cubic metres too much spoil – nearly four times the planned amount – has been transported by lorries through residential areas to the tip, according to a report by surveyors.

Now residents want to know why their complaints to Bromsgrove District Council of over-tipping went unheard. And some are upset by the council’s proposed solution of asking the tip’s developer to apply for “restrospective” permission for the over-tipped waste.

The developer had planning permission for a total of 396,000 cubic metres of material to be brought on to the site.

But an independent report by land surveyors AD Horner, of Pershore, released on June 15, concluded that the volume of waste added to the site exceeded the amount permitted by by 1.08 million cubic metres, making a total of 1.476 million cubic metres.

The report was commissioned by the district council after Ruth Bamford, who had recently become Bromsgrove’s Head of Planning, moved quickly to stop the tipping in March. At the time, she assured residents: “I am personally on the case.”

It looks, however, as if the new hill will remain a permanent feature of the Lickey landscape after the council indicated it would not be asking the developer to remove the excess waste.

Fearing this would cause many more years of lorries arriving – this time to take it away – the council wants to work towards a retrospective planning application which would allow the waste to remain on the site.

So far, no official has come forward to explain how such over-tipping could have taken place, despite repeated and strong complaints by residents over a number of years about the effects the lorries were having on their lives.

The report by AD Horner was presented last month to the Marlbrook Tip Monitoring Group, which includes a number of residents.

According to a district council press release, the group agreed a retrospective planning application was the preferred course of action as there would be too much disruption to residents by removing material.

It added: “The developer should be urged to submit a retrospective planning application that accurately reflects the larger quantity of material that has been added to the former landfill site, and that checks all other matters.”

The release quoted Bromsgrove ’s portfolio holder for Planning, Coun Kit Taylor, saying: “Right from the start of this development it has been clear that through the Tip Monitoring Group the reports of residents would lead to any necessary action at the tip.

“When major local concerns were raised the District Council planning and enforcement officers acted quickly and decisively to put a stop to the tipping at the site, and I would congratulate them on their efforts.”

A number of residents on the monitoring group – some of whom have been reporting fears of over-tipping going back years – later contacted The Village to question the council’s version of events at the meeting.

“The group did not agree to a retrospective planning application to be the preferred course of action,” they said in a letter to us. “No vote was taken at the meeting on this, nor was it agreed that ‘there would be too much disruption to residents by removing the material’.”

When The Village asked Coun Taylor about the residents’ claims, he said: “They interpreted the meeting differently, but what do they want us to do?
“If the residents come up with a viable and a proper plan, then that is something that needs to be looked at.

“I do have every sympathy with the residents, but that is in the past. We can revisit it later to make sure that it doesn’t happen again.

“We now have officers lined up to make sure that what should happen happens,” added Coun Taylor.

See the Village View